Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Electric Lake -- 07/23/05
#1
A friend and I fished Electric Lake all day Saturday. We got a bit of a late start leaving Utah County early Saturday morning, so we didn't arrive at the lake until 9 a.m. Upon arriving, we quickly launched the aluminum 14 footer and oared our way towards the inlet.

After anchoring in about five feet of water, I began fishing a minnow about three feet below a bobber about ten feet from shore. It only took a minute or two before the first cutthroat of the day took my offering. It was rather small, about 12-13 inches, and very skinny.

Its coloring, however, was amazing. Blaze orange cutthroat markings under its mouth, iridescent pastel hues on its gill plates, and countless dark spots running the length of its light-colored body. I released it and a few others like it throughout the early morning as more fish engulfed the suspended minnows I offered and took my bobber for brief runs below the surface of the water.

While fishing for cutts with line and rod, I also fished for minnows via a minnow trap I bought on Friday at Sportsman's. Using a couple pieces of chicken inside the trap, I had poor luck trapping any minnows for the first few hours of the morning.

I could see them swimming all around the trap like miniature sharks swarming a carcass, but they were either too smart or too dumb to make their way into the holes at both ends of the trap. It wasn't until I threw the trap into very shallow water, almost to the point that the top portion of the trap was only a few inches below the water, that I began to trap a few.

Before day's end, I probably only trapped about 30 minnows, but they all came home with me and are now in my freezer awaiting the walleyes at Utah Lake this coming fall and winter. Hopefully, they won't fall apart when I go to use them, as I didn't immediately put them on ice, but they were kept quite cool throughout the day in a cooler I'd brought along.

I believe it was around 11 a.m. or so before I caught my first 16-inch keeper cutthroat, which wasn't so emaciated as its predecessors. Again, it succomed to a minnow suspended below a bobber, although the leader was probably closer to four or five feet by then, as I continued to add space between the hook and the bobber as the sun climbed higher in the sky and we began to fish in deeper water.

The weather at times was downright chilly, which was a welcomed change from the incessant heat we've been experiencing here in the valley for the past month. A few times during the early morning we were rained on rather hard, and at times I was actually wishing that the sun would break through the clouds to warm me up.

We fished E. Lake from about 9 a.m. until 8 p.m. The fishing was never as good throughout the day as it was during the first hour or so after we arrived. In hindsight, then, it would have been great if we would have arrived at the lake closer to 6 a.m. or so, as we probably missed the best fishing of the day by not arriving until 9.

When the fishing was slow, I tried casting Krocodile lures and slow-jigging weightless minnows to no avail. My friend, Les, however, did have fairly steady success on some bigger cutts by casting a weightless minnow, letting it fall, and reeling it in very slowly. He probably hooked up with half a dozen cutts using this method.

His best fish of the day came after he saw some shiners jumping out of the water near the shore and threw his weightless minnow into the fray. His minnow no sooner hit the water and a 17-inch cutt attacked it.

My two best fish came in rapid succession around 4 p.m. as we were drifting with the wind several hundred yards from the inlet. While drifting past a fairly shallow, flooded stretch of shoreline I caught two 17-inch, big-shouldered cutts within seconds of each other.

From then on as the evening progressed, the fishing became less and less steady. Les seemed to do the best as the sun began to sink behind the distant mountains, catching most of his while slow-reeling his weightless minnows off the bottom. As the light began to fade, bobber fishing became nearly fruitless.

All in all it was a wonderful day high in the mountains in Fairview Canyon. What a beautiful spot E. Lake is. It's always nice to get high enough in elevation to fish amidst aspens and pines, "where the deer and the antelope (or elk, in this case) play."

The only negative that I care to mention is concerning the size of the cutthroats we caught. With all of the shiners swimming around in that lake, one would think that some big cutts would call that place home. Yes, we did catch some fairly long fish, but not one of them was what I would consider fat. I know the lake is in an area where it's very cold for much of the year, but still, the cutts sure seemed skinny. Any thoughts as to why we didn't catch fatter fish?

Skinny fish aside, I'm sure glad we made the trip. I haven't fished for an entire day like that in a very long time. I'd recommend it, if any of you are so inclined. That's about all I have to say. Hope you enjoy the report.
[signature]
Reply
#2
great report!!
E-lake as most here know is a my hang out when i'm not out for warm water fish.. the wether up there can be cool or even down right cold even in july and august..so if you go up there make sure that you take so warm clothes with ya..

i think the fish size in E-lake is disapointing as well!! with as much food as there is in that lake the fish should be monster size by now.. if your lucky and happon to get a rainbow out of E-lake you will see the diffrence!! the rainbows are getting some size to them and are fat as well.. the yellowstone cutt's just dont seam to be doing any good there as far as size go's..

maybe some day the DWR will give up on those stinking cutt's but i dont think so..they seam to think that it's the only fish on that mountain that matter to anyone.. i think that E-lake could be as good of a big fish fishery as the berry or scofield if only it had some fish in it that would grow!! the rainbows in there have proved that over the last years that i have fished it.. evey rainbow i have cought there have been if not long at lest they have been fat and in good shape..

glad to hear you got to see and fish one of my favorite places to fish and just hang out.. one of the most beautiful lake i have ever fished..

here are 2 of the rainbows we have cought out of E-lake..note the size!! then think of the size of the cutt's you were catching.. there is a big diffrence!!
[signature]
Reply
#3
Hey Ron,

One thing I forgot to mention in my post is that I appreciated all of the advice you gave me. I doubt I would have caught as many fish if I hadn't read all of your great reports on E. Lake.

Those are some very nice rainbows. I wish I would have caught a couple like that. Did you catch them using the same tactics that you use for cutts (i.e., minnows)?

As far as the cutts being very skinny, I was thinking about one particular cutthroat whose mouth was full of shiners that my friend caught. It's a mystery to me as to why the cutts aren't huge with how voraciously they prey upon the plentiful minnows up there.

One more thing: After bringing home my limit of four cutthroat, I carefully filleted and skinned each one so that I was left with eight boneless, skinless fillets for the frying pan. I fried them in butter, fresh-squeezed lemon juice, dill, and a bit of seasoned salt.

It was by far the best fish my family and I have eaten in a long time, and recently we've eaten plenty of catfish, bass, bluegill, and a few crappie. My kids couldn't get enough of it and ate it all in the one setting.

For those of you who claim that trout aren't that tasty, I'd recommend removing the skin before cooking, as I believe that's where most of the fishy taste comes from. Eating those fish was a nice end to a great time fishing E. Lake.
[signature]
Reply
#4
oh yeah they hit the minnows!!
the rainbow i'm holding up was last summer..
the one my boy is holding up was about 3 weeks ago..that one was right around 21" or 22" and around 3 lbs..


i would like for everyone that go's to E-lake to keep all the cutt's that they can!! and turn lose any and all rainbows and browns that they catch.. that way there is a chance that there is at lest some fish in there that can get some size to them!!
[signature]
Reply
#5
I take it, then, that the rainbows in E. Lake aren't sterile like the ones the UDWR plant in Strawberry? Do you know if the 'bows in E. Lake are able reproduce?
[signature]
Reply
#6
The Bows in E Lake come down the stream from Benches Lake. They should not be sterile. The Yellowstone Cutts that I have caught in Yellowstone National Park have never been heavy fish, but at least up there they do tend to get longer than they get in E Lake. I doubt that they have any longer growing period in YNP than they do in E Lake.
[signature]
Reply
#7
I thought chicken was meant for crawdad traps instead of minnow traps? Has anyone else tried chicken in a minnow trap?
[signature]
Reply
#8
It's what Ocean recommended I use, and it worked like a charm. I used the fattiest, uncooked skin I could find off of a couple of pieces.
[signature]
Reply
#9
I havent, atleast not intentionally but I have caught a few mini's while baited with chicken for mudbugs.. And to this point I havent found much that beats bread loaded with the "A-juice" when it comes to trappin' mini's...
[signature]
Reply
#10
Up here in Idaho at Henry's Lake the Yellowstone cutthroats get huge! And I have never caught a skinny one, in fact I have noticed them to be much fatter than the bonnevilles you guys have.
[signature]
Reply
#11
that's probably because the yellowstone cutt's are from that area!!
they are not from around here tho!!
bonnevilles or bearlake cutt's would do much better in lakes around this area.. because they are from around this area..

the problem is convincing the utah DWR of that.. duh let's see if we can take a fish from it's native invironment and make it live somewhere it's not going to do well in.. then make it so the fisherman can't even catch them for half the year in the rivers and see how many skinny snaky looking fish we can make the fisherman of utah catch and think there doing good because there are so many of them all over the place!!
sounds like the utah DWR to me!!
[signature]
Reply
#12
I'm almost afraid to ask this, but what is "A-juice"?
[signature]
Reply
#13
I'm quite certain it stands for "Fish attractant juice.
[signature]
Reply
#14
knowing Don i'm sure it would be anchove smelley jelly.. it allso go's good on a peanut butter sandwitch... lol

the best thing i have found up there is just a plain Bubba's Bagel.. just put it in the trap no need to try and role it up or any thing just throw it in them thing's last all day long and the minnows seam to like them as much as i do!!
[signature]
Reply
#15
[cool]PrinceFisher: I saw you and your buddy on Saturday up there. Didn't know that was you. Should have said hi to ya. Sorry about that. I was wearing my bigfishtackle shirt. I got there at about 7:30 or so and had great fishing till the rain came up at around 11? or maybe a bit earlier than that. It was raining so hard that we said "let's get back to camp and get some breakfast" so off we went. I was with my sister in law (that blond chick) and her husband. We set out our minnow trap and followed fuzzyfisher's directions. We first set it in a dropoff spot like the one we were fishing, but didn't get more than a couple, so we then tried the shallow area that almost looked like a boat launch about 50 yards away from where we were fishing. "Ding-ding!" That was the ticket. After about 20 minutes or so, we had about 35-40 minnows. We were using a tightly balled up piece of white bread (the good kind-Grandma Sycamore's). Wish we could have stayed longer, but we were hungry and the very cold rain came down (in laws live in Florida, so they aren't used to that cold stuff this time of year). We caught around 6 fish in the couple of hours that we were there and probably missed three times that many bites at least. Think I need to go to the Japanese hooks, as they are sharper and get quicker hooksets. Gonna get me some Matsuo's.

Went to Scofield that night for Crawdads and some shore fishing by the dam. Caught about 100 crawdads in about 3 hours, and we all got skunked (even with minnows for bait, no less) with the fish, except for my bro in law who caught a nice 18 inch cut and a smaller bow about 12 or 13 inches. Still a good time and better than sitting around doing nothing.

Monday morning we went back to E-Lake (just the sis in law and me, cause Josh wanted to stay in his bed and sleep in). Well, we should have stayed back at camp too rather than get skunked in the 43 degree cold. Got there about 6, returned to our beds at camp at around 8 or so.

Great weekend, and it was beautiful up there. As we expected, it was more lush than usual, and wildflowers everywhere, and it was great to get out of the heat and smog of the SL Valley. Hope to make it back up there a time or two before the end of the summer.
[signature]
Reply
#16
I'm still not sure which group of people you were on the shore. There were a few groups fishing within a few hundred yards of the boat launch when we began fishing around 9.

Glad you had some success, and you're right about it being a beautiful spot. Like you, I'd like to get up there a couple more times before summer ends.
[signature]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)