chub minnows, or redsides

[fencekid971]

which do you prefer? sometimes when you buy frozen minnows at sportsmans wharehouse you have a choice. chub or redside. some folks think that a minnow is a minnow and some swear buy one or the other. do ya think it matters? or do you think one works better than the other.
[signature]

[aquaman]

neither i would rather use small sucker minnows next would be redsides then chub
[signature]

[Shrimpboy]

First - baby june sucker
Second - live gizzard shad
Third - spotted owl cut up into 1 inch chuncks
Fourth - bald eagle chicks butterflied and soaked in anise

Actually I agree...you can't beat sucker...whether it's cut up or in whole minnow form.
[signature]

[FlyingFish]

Mmmmm anise bald eagle.
[signature]

[ocean]

I guess that depends on the body of water you are fishing and the species.But red shiners have worked well for me.
[signature]

[cat_man]

Speaking of Carp, I'm heading out today on my lunch break to the pond at the end of the parking lot here at Novell. Got me a couple pieces of bread and a fishing pole. Gonna try and catch me some carp for kitty bait. Hopefully I can catch a bunch of the smaller ones instead of the big 10 pounders. They're really gonna appreciate me stocking the breakroom freezer with dead carp this afternoon!!! [cool][]
[signature]

[Coldfooter]

LMAO! Yeah they'll just love ya for that! But on the other hand, why not use the dead space, huh? Still LMAO!
[signature]

[cat_man]

Exactly.
[signature]