Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Catch and ???
#1
I don't mean to step on any toes but, Does anyone out there actually eat what they catch? I read so many posts that one guy says "I caught a monster this week end" then he is asked "did you release it?" to which he replies "but of course". It sounds like a Grey poupon commercial.
I just want to know if I'm the last guy that actually enjoys a deepfried smallie.
[signature]
Reply
#2
I will eat my catch probably 90% of the time. I wont hook and cook if it's un-ethical, like a good sized female waleye before the spawn or if there's no way I could eat the fish before they go bad. But on the whole I love a good fish fry. I'll be up in the Uintahs this weekend a boy how I look forward to cooking a fresh caught fish on the fire. A little butter, seasoning, and a slice of lemon. Mmmmmmmm. I'm drooling already.
[signature]
Reply
#3
[#505000]I also keep and eat quite a bit. I usually release more trout than other fish because they are so easy to catch and I don't like them as much. Too fishy. [/#505000]
[#505000][/#505000]
[#505000]I release some cats but I love their flavor and keep more than I release. [/#505000]
[#505000][/#505000]
[#505000]Other than a select few I take home to become bait. I release all the carp I catch with my bow. [Tongue][/#505000]
[signature]
Reply
#4
I keep a few small ones on occasion. I love to make an artichoke dip every now and again and add smallmouth meat to it where you would normally use crab and it tastes oh so good spread over some toast or on some chips.

I have only harvested about 10 smallmouth under 12 inches all year. Release the big ones please. Smile Since you can't keep them anyways.
[signature]
Reply
#5
I'm a bit of a hypocrite when it comes to keeping fish. If it is a body of water that I feel personally connected to I never keep fish like the green river, jones hole and a few Uinta lakes, but if it is just a fishing hole I keep what I can use in a day or two. Anything over a good meal goes back. I almost never freeze fish unless I get into a big mess of perch or bluegill; or unless I'm keeping it as bait. I seldomly keep big fish, they just don't eat as well as smaller ones. I'm cautious about prespawn females. I almost never keep bass; I don't enjoy LMB and I seldomly catch smallies of a size I can keep (under 12 at jordanelle, over 12 @ rockport, over 16 @ pineview).
[signature]
Reply
#6
I end up releasing most of my fish, but I will keep a mess o fish every once in a while. Only keep what I eat. I hate to see "hockey pucks" in the freezer.
[signature]
Reply
#7
[#505000]I am a little guilty of the hockey puck supply in the freezer, but I do find I thaw and eat a lot too so I don't feel too bad about it. I also find if it has been in there longer than a month I give it to my folks who don't fish but love to eat it. [/#505000]
[signature]
Reply
#8
I keep what I can use. Never put fish in the freezer, it just doesn't taste as good and you always need and excuse to to go fish for more. As for bass, they are ok,but, perch, bluegill, trout are just as good and you don't have to feel guilty about keeping them.
[signature]
Reply
#9
I love certain kinds of fish to eat, especially walleyes and crappie. I'll keep some smallmouth and some rainbows, too. But I don't keep any really big fish to eat. In my opinion, a really large game fish is too valuable a resource to die for my dinner.

A 25 lb. lake trout will be 20-25 years old and I don't want to see that resource disappear. Any fish I kill that is that old cannot be replaced in my lifetime. So as a matter of personal choice I don't kill any of those big fish. I'd rather have the chance to catch the same fish at 30 or 35 lbs.

To me, it's a matter of trying to keep the few remaining trophy fisheries viable.

I think it is Lee Wulff who is widely quoted as coining the phrase: "A gamefish is too valuable to be caught only once."
[signature]
Reply
#10
Nothing wrong with a delicious bass now and then. I dined on them last sunday and felt no guilt whatsoever.[shocked]

I don't like grey poop on my sandwiches either....
[signature]
Reply
#11
Well its good to know I'm not the only one out there that actually eats one once in awhile. But I have to agree with putting the big ones back, The muskie I caught the other day was amazing and not saying anything about the people that mount them but I just prefer to put them back and let someone else experience it. (besides it wasn't big enough to keep anyway) [Tongue]
[signature]
Reply
#12
That's funny, I thought it was Jim Zumbo who said it best: "Catch and release in warm butter."
[signature]
Reply
#13
As a general rule I keep just about everything I catch. I don't keep smallies or LMB unless DWR recommends doing so on certain waters for population control. I don't fish for snot rockets if I deep hook one by mistake I'll keep it and eat it. I hate wasting fish more than I hate the taste of trout. I eat what I catch either the same day or the next day. I never freeze fresh fish (except carp for bait). If I have more than I can eat the next day I fire up the old smoker and then vacuum seal it and store it in the fridge... or I store the smoked fish in the freezer but usually it is eaten too fast to worry about freezing it.

The big problem with home freezers is the freezer doesn't freeze quickly enough to maintain the cell structure of the fresh fish so quality goes down fast (it's not spoiled obviously but the texture is just wrong). An alternative I saw on TV ("Good Eats" gotta love Alton Brown) is to use Dry Ice to instantly freeze the fish then vacuum seal it and you have the equivelent of flash freezing fish like they do on the commercial fishing boats. The Dry Ice thing is just too much trouble for me at this point. Unfortunately, I usually don't catch enough fish to make "too much fish" a problem. Fresh or fresh cooked is definitely better IMO.
[signature]
Reply
#14
I hope this doesn't strike people as funny but I catch about 500 to 700 trout per summer and don't keep a one. I used to work for EDS and had a couple of long stints in Ecuador and "got used" to eating see bass, I also eat tuna when I travel to Boston and ate a lot of mahi-mahi and wahoo when I lived in S. Florida. I also buy the "shrink wrapped" fresh frozen salmon at Costco. After eating all this fish, trout just "doesn't do it for me!" I do like walleye (if I could only catch some [Sad]) and perch and will definitely eat those fish if I catch them but that's it.

Actually, I have been lately considering finding a friend that likes trout and keeping a few sub-14 inchers out of the Provo in hopes of fattening up the bigun's! Anyone out there like trout and live in Heber??? [Wink]

Now an interesting point that has been brought up... smallmouth bass. I always release but I am under the impression they are about as good as perch! However, I have always felt it would be looked down upon to keep them? I kind of feel like some of y'all think keeping a few of the small ones might improve the fishery... in this case Jordanelle. Should I eat a few 12 inchers?
[signature]
Reply
#15
[#505000]Ahh DRY ICE!! Eureka!!!!!! That is a thought that has been eluding me for weeks. I like to fish with minnows I've caught but unless you use them right away they turn to mush when frozen. I'll have to try the Dry Ice and see how they turn out.[/#505000]
[signature]
Reply
#16
I would imagine that minnows would freeze perfectly with iths methods they are small and will freeze solid in seconds. The key apparently is to put the minnows in the fridge for a few hours to lower the temperature so the freezing happens faster. The method recommended crushing the dry ice (probably with a hammer in to small pieces) it into a bowl and toss in the minnows and and cover the bowl with a dish towel and put the bowl into a cooler as close to the size of the bowl as possible for about 20 minutes and then you'll have some nice minnow sickles. I'm curious how it'll turn out. LMK. The minnows from sportmans suffer from the mushie fishie syndrome it would be great to have an alternative.
[signature]
Reply
#17
C'mon Gary, you know you wanted the dry ice to make dry ice bombs with! JK. Let us know if it works well, cause getting a bunch of minnows all nice and froze would be nice for ice fishin'. Of course I could order some liquid nitrogen (perk of working in a Dr's office) and you could drop the little buggars in there, that would freeze them up real quick like.
[signature]
Reply
#18
Go figure... never could have guessed from your id that you keep and eat. [Wink]
[signature]
Reply
#19
[#505000]That may even work better!! How expensive is it??? [/#505000]
[#505000][/#505000]
[#505000]Just make sure you don't drop them after or you will be picking up minnow shards for awhile!! [Tongue][/#505000]
[signature]
Reply
#20
It seems like the UDWR is pretty good about advising fisherpersons about which waters need fish to be harvested out of them and which don't.

For instance, when writing of Strawberry Reservoir, I remember the UDWR stating, "please do not feel compelled to harvest fish on every trip" or something to that effect. This, of course, is due to Strawberry being Utah's most popular fishing destination.

If everyone who fished Strawberry brought home a limit of fish each time he/she fished it, then the reservoir's fish populations would be affected greatly in short order, or so I suppose, or else the UDWR wouldn't have made such a statement.

However, we all know that each body of water in Utah has its own unique characteristics and needs. Take Utah Lake, as another example. The UDWR recently called this body of water "Utah's Most Underutilized Fishery," or something like that. Yes, a lot of people fish UL, but beyond the occasional limit of monster catfish and the truckloads full of white bass of yesteryear, does this body of water really experience a lot of fish harvest given how large it is?

Nearly everybody I talk to says UL is too dirty and polluted to eat fish out of. Well, let them think what they may because after all I've read and heard, I feel assured that it's perfectly safe to eat the fish I catch out of UL, and I do, most happily.

I don't feel like I have to apologize for eating just about any walleye I catch out of UL. I love catching and eating the toothy delectables more than just about another fish, and until I read of some study from the UDWR or another group of educated folks, I'll legally go on harvesting 'eyes out of UL as fast as I can catch them.

Then, there are other waters from which our state's resource managers practically beg us to take fish. Lake Powell (stripers), stretches of the Provo River (brown trout), Flaming Gorge (smaller lake trout), and other waters are apparently overrun with certain species of fish; therefore, fisherpersons are encouraged to harvest them.

All of these recommendations impact my decisions when I'm fishing various waters and considering whether or not to bring home fish to eat. The older I get, the more I lean towards bringing more and more fish home, not to freeze mind you, but to enjoy as the freshest of main courses for a dinner or two.

There seems to be this mentality that says, "If I practice catch and release, I'm a conservationist, and I'm saving the planet." Well, those who practice C & R are doing their part to conserve and are doing a good thing, but if I choose to bring home an evening's meal worth of fish, I'm not necessarily ruining the planet for future generations either.

Please be considerate enough not to try and make me feel like the guy who conked the last-remaining dodo bird on the head or the guy who ran the Exxon Valdez loaded with oil into some rocks off the pristine coast of Alaska, if I choose to put a fish on my stringer after I've caught it out of your beloved body of water.

There are those who fish who ALWAYS release what they catch, those who keep a fish occasionally, and those who try to "limit out" each time they approach a body of water.

Somehow, it all seems to equal itself out, and if it doesn't, I trust the UDWR to issue recommendations that I hope people have enough sense to follow.

I've said enough.

One more thing: I've been fishing for warm-water species now for quite some time, so the first big legal trout I hook into, no matter where I catch it, it's darn sure going home with me. Just thought I'd issue that warning to all you big trout out there. [Wink]
[signature]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)