Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Scofield Holiday Fun
#1
I'm new here so I don't want to start beef with anyone but I would like to defend Scofield Reservoir a little bit. Recently as I have read through the forum I have seen quite a few negative posts dogging on Scofield and what a poor fishery it has become. I have lived in Price, UT for about 20 years now and Scofield like many lakes has had good years and bad years. The one unique thing about the lake is it can turn on and off overnight. I have spent many weekends camping there and have killed them on a Saturday and then spent an entire Sunday motoring all over the lake without a bite. I agree the chubs are a pain and are getting worse, but they do make nice bait. The big change in the lake was when the crawfish were eliminated a few years ago, I saw a decrease in fish size and numbers of big fish. But in 2012 the DWR planted 76,000 fish and in 2013 they planted 82,000 fish - so you should be able to catch one.

So there's my 2 cents![Tongue] The trick to finding fish this time of year is move. Don't just drill a new hole 20 feet away, I mean pack up your stuff and drag it clear across the lake or load it up and drive around the lake. The lake is shallow and the fish move around a lot! The fish tend to travel in schools so if someone in your party gets a bite everyone needs to pay attention to their pole and start jigging, and if you land one, get that rig back in the water fast. If you miss the school bus you need to wait for the next one to come by.

During the holidays I had the pleasure of hitting the lake 3 times and did fairly well. The first day on the 23rd I took the kids to the dam arm (because it was supposed to be hot), we sat for 3 hours and landed a chub. Packed it up and moved to Madsen and started to get into them.

During the fishing derby I took my daughter and a friend (I'm the bearded guy) we landed quite few but nothing for the judges. We started at Madsen and was not landing enough so we packed it up and went across from the state park which was a bad idea! Landed nothing but 6" bows and chubs. We only had about an hour and a half to fish so we headed back towards Madsen and stopped at a few abandoned holes that payed off well. We actually missed the weigh-in because the action was so hot. We figured we didn't have a winner so why not keep fishing!

And the last trip was New Years Eve with the old man and the boy. We decided to hit Madsen again and guess what - no fish! We moved to the state park, to the east highway, and back to Madsen. As we were leaving I decided to take the auger up against the rocks by Madsen boat ramp in about 8' of water and finally found them! We had only about an hour to fish before it got dark and cold but we landed enough for dinner.

I also attached a picture of my fish-finder, it rents for about $25 an hour! Happy fishing!
[signature]
Reply
#2
I don't want to know how you change the batteries in that fishfinder.

Welcome to the BFT website. I'm in the same part of the state. We'll probably meet one of these days. I agree with a lot of what you said about Scofield. I fished it when it first had safe ice in December. I did OK when you consider how many smaller trout there are in the lake. Those small trout will continue to grow and I see a bright future for the lake. The Southeastern Region DWR folks know their stuff and I'm sure they will do what is best for the resource.

Enjoy Scofield for what it provides in the way of fast action on most days. There are plenty of other waters to try your luck. Variety is the spice of life.

Mike
[signature]
Reply
#3
I don't ice fish much but I know Scofield is a great place to fish when it open water. The chubs are a problem but because of the abundance of chubs there has been a new state record tiger trout caught each of the last two years. The plan that the DWR has come up with for Scofield is a good one, with poisoning as a last resort. We fishermen are a patient bunch until it comes to letting nature and wildlife managers do there thing.
By the way, I don't think that fish finder could stay down a whole hour for the $25.[laugh]
[signature]
Reply
#4
ah yes!! your fish finder is what we call "polardicken" works well in in shallow water! [Smile]
[signature]
Reply
#5
I think most of the Debbie Downers about Scofield stopped posting this fall when a few of us kept coming back from trips up there with pictures like this:

[inline "James 24in Cutt Scofield Oct2013.jpg"]

[inline "26in Cutt Scofield Oct2013.jpg"]

[inline "Scofield 27in Cutt Nov16.jpg"]

[inline "Dad with 23in Cutt Scofield Halloween 2013.jpg"]
[signature]
Reply
#6
I love the fish finder! I don't fish scofield much but I do believe the management plan the DWR has is going to work. Scofield is on it's way back. Thanks for the report!
[signature]
Reply
#7
How far down the hole can that fish finder record. Any special features with it???? [laugh]
[signature]
Reply
#8
I enjoyed your post, that fish finder is one of a kind!!!

This debate about scofield is intriguing, ....people cry for a trophy fisheries , and people cry about not catching enough fish.... If anyone knows of the pond lake or stream that you can consistently catch 5-8 lb fish every half hour every day of the year .... Please please let me know

What do you want people ... Community ponds, or trophy fisheries.
Take into consideration how difficult it would be to manage a lake this size , and the traffic it gets year round.

Everyone gets consumed with some fish story on BFt about how some guy caught 60 fish in a day or every time I go I land a 7 lb bow.
Hogwash, it's called fishing, not catching.

Don't get me started on the chubs , if you think it's bad now, then you never experienced the 80's.
I say grow up whiners
[signature]
Reply
#9
Great pics. Those are some beauties!
[signature]
Reply
#10
The fish finder is 7 years old so it is pretty noisy and eats a lot of fuel, but it still makes me happy.
[signature]
Reply
#11
[quote DesertRat]The fish finder is 7 years old so it is pretty noisy and eats a lot of fuel, but it still makes me happy.[/quote]

I guess that is what counts then![cool]
[signature]
Reply
#12
Gotta get some Raider gear out on that ice.....probably would've won the tourney with some Silver and Black out there with ya !
[signature]
Reply
#13
Nice pics and report, but you've got a picture with Broncos gear and Chiefs gear... that's blaspheme!

Broncos gear is a requirement!

Is anyone catching small chubs or even seen any? if so, where? ( I need some bait) If not I'd have to say the management plan is paying off already.
[signature]
Reply
#14
+1 to MasterDaad! If anything increased pressure is just making the fish smarter is all. We just need to refine our tactics a bit. He's just doing right what other's aren't I personally haven't landed any records, but I don't have too much trouble getting into fish when I do go. I think some of the prettiest fish I have ever caught have been the tigers out of Scofield. Especially if you can manage to catch them when they are all oranged up (not a word but you get the idea.) It makes every fish a trophy in my eyes. If we are really worried about the fishery then we need to do our part to take care of the fish that we catch and release. and kill all the chubs we find. If we all do our part it should be great for years to come. Just my 2 cents.
[signature]
Reply
#15
Great report! Enjoyed the read and the pics
THanks
[signature]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: